Banana Skins and the Countryside

Q. Hi

Last time I was in the Yorkshire Dales I absently tossed my banana skin over a wall only to be (good humouredly) admonished by my walking pals that is does not do the countryside any good.

Is this true?

Surely since banana skins are organic matter and bio-degradeable they will just rot into the soil providing much needed nutrients?

Thanks,

Jamie Elkstone, Richmond


A. Banana skins, orange peel, apple cores and bread crusts are all litter

Here's why you really should take these things home (they're usually lighter than when you brought them out at this point anyway - so you can't complain about the weight.)

  1. The stuff will rot and will improve the soil. This might, at first, seem like a good thing to do. If, however, you are a rare alpine or arctic plant humming gently to yourself in the breeze on the top of an English mountain, the very last thing you want is for somebody to come and feed the local grass which will grow quickly and shade you out in no time. The stuff you drop takes a long time to rot anyway, particularly in winter.
  2. The hills do have a resident population of rats, crows, gulls and so on - especially in areas popular with people - because they know that people are incontinent of food. Feeding these will increase their numbers, and they, in turn, will eat wild bird eggs and chicks. Not feeding them will help them achieve a more natural balance. In terms of rodents - they are inside that summit cairn you were sitting on last weekend you know - its by no means too cold for them up on Scafell Pike. Its an easy life - the food just drops through the stones.
  3. Its a dirty, unsightly, horrible habit and a bad example to children, so don't do it.

Mike Knipe, Crook



Add your answer to THIS question | Ask a NEW walking and hiking question

Return to the main list of Walking and Hiking Questions

Search for an existing Walking and Hiking Question or Answer


Do not miss our pick of the Best Walks in the UK


Follow go4awalk.com on Twitter Follow go4awalk.com on Facebook


Home


Find new Friends to go walking with

Walk all 214 Wainwrights in just 59 Walks. Download GPS Waypoints - Great Walks you must not miss!

Walk The Yorkshire Three Peaks Challenge Walk - All the Latest Route Information, GPS Waypoints and Split Times to keep you on Schedule

Walk The British Three Peaks Challenge Walk - All the Latest Route Information and GPS Waypoints

See our pick of The Best Walks in The Lake District - Great Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of the Best Lake District Ridge Walks - Great Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of the Best Lake District Walks to do in the rain - Great Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Walks in Snowdonia - Great Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Ridge Walks in Wales - Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Walks in The Brecon Beacons - Great Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Walks in The Yorkshire Dales - Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Walks in The Peak District - Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Walks in The Forest of Bowland - Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Walks in Shropshire - Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Walks in Cheshire - Walks you must not miss!

Walk our pick of The Best Walks in Lancashire - Walks you must not miss!

Not sure where to walk next? Try Peak Bagging - Great Walks you must not miss!

Not sure where to walk next? Walk part of a National Trail - Great Walks you must not miss!

Walks with Downloadable and Uploadable GPS Waypoint Data

Walking Kit and Gear Tested by Walkers

Full Site Search
Do not miss our pick of the Best Walks in the UK